Trust is a precursor to health engagement. Trust impacts health outcomes such as a patient’s willingness to follow a doctor’s or health plan’s instructions. Two new studies point out that U.S. consumers don’t trust every touchpoint in the health system. Online medical information has become a trusted channel. Health plans? Not so much.

Wolters Kluwer’s Health Q1 Poll on Self-Diagnosis found that consumers trust online health information to inform themselves — even for self-diagnosis. 57% of U.S. adults turn to the Internet to find answers to medical information; 25% “never” do, and 18% rarely do. Two-thirds of people say they trust the information they find: 70% of health information seekers with college and advanced degrees trust medical information on the Internet.

Among health information seekers online, 63% say they’ve “never” had a misdiagnosis.

Furthermore, 67% of health information seekers believe that access to this information makes them better informed patients.

Underlying peoples’ search for health information online are barriers to patient-physician communication. In a 2011 poll among physicians from Wolters Kluwer, Overwhelmingly the number one barrier that physicians identify is lack of time, cited by 78% of physicians. Over one-half of physicians, though, believe that patients are misinformed. Nearly one-half believe that doctors have information overload, also compromising doctor-patient communication. Still, only 12% of physicians believe that patient access to online medical information has impeded the quality of care they provide, and two-thirds have changed an initial diagnosis due to new information accessed online.

The first chart illustrates what consumers do once they access health information online. First, most discuss the information with their doctors, across all age groups. Second, health information seekers discuss the information they find with family and friends, more commonly done by younger patients age 18-34. Social media is still a limited channel for most patients, about 9% of whom discuss self-diagnoses via social media.

Thus, online health information is trusted, even for self-diagnosis. But health insurance plans should be envious of online health information’s position on the trust league table, because about 50% of consumers do not trust their health insurer, according to Peppers & Rogers Group’s report, Measuring the Value of Trust in Healthcare.

The majority of  health insurers’ customers do not trust their health plans: only 43% of health plan enrollees trust their plans, while 38% distrust them and 19% are neutral. However, other health ecosystem players are trusted, such as the patient’s physician and pharmacist, with 46% and 43% greater trust, according to Peppers & Rogers’ survey data. “Thus, distrusters are not simply malcontents,” P&R writes: “they distinctly distrust their health insurer.”

The second chart presents P&R’s survey data comparing consumers’ perceptions on trust of health plans. By far, the #1 trusted plan is Kaiser Permanente. But even for mighty K-P, there are nearly 50% neutral or distrusting: fewer than for the national plans, but still very challenging.

P&R suggests four “essentials” for health insurers to create consumer trust:

  1. Know me, integrating consumer insights with health support for behavior change and sustainment.
  2. Show me that you know me, by customizing personal interactions.
  3. Engage me, creating reasons for consumers to have meaningful dialogue with health plans.
  4. Be transparent, providing opportunities for rating and commenting on services, feedback to the plan, and demonstrating openness with consumers.
P&R found that plans that demonstrate trustworthy behavior and earn consumers’ trust can capture higher prices — on average, $29 more per month.
Health Populi’s Hot Points:  Patients are split on whether they’d rely on the Internet to diagnose or treat an illness. 41% overall would not rely on the Internet for diagnosis or treatment — which leaves 59% who would. This varies across age cohorts, but not as much as you might think. Among the oldest patients 55 and over, 51% said they’d never rely on the Internet for diagnosis or treatment – leaving 50% who would.

In the emerging healthcareDIY era, marked by consumer-directed health plans, health insurance exchanges, and a growing roster of online and mobile tools for consumers to track and treat their own health at home and on-the-go, trust will be a key currency for business viability. These two studies demonstrate where consumers are finding trust — and identify the opportunity for health plans to break away from the pack if they engage patients transparently, supportively, and personally.

8 Comments on Consumer trust in health care: online information trumps health plans

Health Care Plans – Portal Korea said : Guest Report 3 years ago

[…] Types of Health Insurance Plan – Source […]

Finding Quality Doctors: What the Public Thinks | American Hospital Association Resource Center Blog said : Guest Report 5 years ago

[…] Sarasohn-Kahn J. Consumer trust in health care: online information trumps health plans. HealthPopuli.com, May 21, 2012. https://healthpopuli.com/2012/05/21/consumer-trust-in-health-care-online-information-trumps-health-pl… […]

Marketing To Consumers: Carpe Diem – ConnectedHealth said : Guest Report 6 years ago

[…] one of the biggest challenges many health plans have is in the brand equity they have with consumers. All too often, research suggests that consumers […]

critical illness life insurance said : Guest Report 6 years ago

Excellent blog here! Also your site loads up verry fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my webb site loaded up as quickly as youes lol

A handful of health plans adopts HIT to get closer to consumers | Health Populi said : Guest Report 7 years ago

[...] Chilmark points to a critical obstacle for health plans in the consumer space: that is, dipping a toe in for the short-run, but withdrawing before consumers get the hang of engagement. Not taking a long(er) view is preventing these health plans from learning about how patients engage in health. Furthermore, by delaying such engagement, plans lack the dialogue with patients they need to have to develop a trusted relationship with these end-users of the plan. Moore rightly points out that health plans aren’t the most trusted nexus for health engagement. Only 38% of U.S. health consumers trust their health plans, according to Peppers & Rogers 2012 research, Measuring the Value of Trust in Healthcare, which I discussed in Health Populi in May 2012. [...]

Online medical information has become a trusted channel /  Montana Healthcare Solutions said : Guest Report 7 years ago

[...] Read more at https://healthpopuli.com/2012/05/21/consumer-trust-in-health-care-online-information-trumps-health-pl.... [...]

Consumer trust in health care: online information trumps health … | news update for you life said : Guest Report 7 years ago

[...] Consumer trust in health care: online information trumps health … « Fox News Sunday Panel on Obama, Romney, and 2012 | The … Game of Thrones Ascent [...]

Adam Kaufman said : Guest Report 7 years ago

Thanks for referencing your 2010 article on trust as a precursor to engagement. There is a lot of energy now, it seems, towards engaging patients/members and supporting behavior change. Its important to remember that whether its the health plan, the provider, a third party company, etc. that self-management support is built on a relationship and relationships are built on trust.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked