9 in 10 Americans who know the health system — those with a serious illness, medical condition, injury or disability — believe that health care costs are a serious problem for the nation. This problem has gotten worse over the last 5 years, according to 70% of sick Americans.

The Sick in America Poll, from National Public Radio, Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, and the Harvard School of Public Health, was released May 2012. The survey presents a picture of the 27% of Americans who use the health system and, as a result of their illness or disability, encounter financial challenges.

When asked what factors are responsible for rising health care costs in the U.S., large majorities of ill Americans say “it’s the charges,” pointing to organizations charging too much money for products and services: these include drug companies (85%), hospitals (78%), insurance companies (75%), and doctors (58%).

But 70% of patients also say that it’s people not taking good care of their health that’s driving up health care utilization and, thus, costs for more medical treatment. [This is the argument for avoidable health costs — conditions amenable to prevention — often discussed in Health Populi].

Other cost drivers cited by the sick are fraud and abuse (61%), lack of coordinated care which leads to duplication of tests and treatments (54%), and 51% of people noting population aging, government regulation, and Medicare and Medicaid spending out of control.

Health Populi’s Hot Points: There’s an important data point that might get lost in the mass media coverage of this poll, but critical for solving the problem of costs and bending that increasing curve: that is, getting patients more involved in their own care. The sick patients polled in this survey recognize that people aren’t taking good care of themselves, which leads to greater health spending. When asked the question, “When you go see a doctor for a specific medical issue, would you prefer the doctor focus on just trying to resolve the issue or the doctor spend time discussing other, broader health issues that might affect your long-term health,” 72% of patients preferred the later, more global health approach to personal health.

This means that patients seek greater time with physicians: 47% told the pollsters that doctors and nurses don’t spend enough time with patients in a question on reasons for problems with quality of care, along with 44% saying people not following through on the advice or treatment recommendations of their doctors.

Patients familiar with the health system recognize that the system is broken — lacking coordination of care, team-based care and communication, and a workflow that brings patients into communications and self-care loops. Patient-centered medical homes, coupled with arming patients with patient-centered designed tools and communications platforms that patients will want to use, would help to close the patient engagement gap that’s leading to ineffective health spending.




5 Comments on Sick of health care costs in America

HealthPopuli.com said : Guest Report 4 years ago

[…] for controlling healthcare spending.” As a health economist keen on the Triple/Quadruple Aim, I’ve been pointing this out for many years, this from a 2012 Health Populi post — there’s no bending the health care cost curve […]

Dr md murray said : Guest Report 10 years ago

I agree with PTWonk - Americans dont realise that they are being manipulated by an multibillion dollar industry and its lobbyiests . So the stakes are high and there are massive sums to be made. In reality the US spend half the health care budget in the world and has the highest infant mortality, child mortality, maternal mortality, highest teenage pregnancy rate and shortest life expectancy in the developed world and is ranked below Bostwana for immunisation rates. However when a cost effective universal health care is suggested utter nonsence appears talking about "death panels" - the Harvard study that showed 42,000 extra deaths in the unisured are simply denied by people like Rick Santorum. it is always interesting that people who claim to be Christian feel strongly about sharing some of their taxes to prevent other people dying and instead call it "socialist|" and seem to shoot themselves in the foot as this would be against the great American way of life to be able to die of a preventable condition because you cant afford not to.

PTWonk said : Guest Report 10 years ago

Missed cause. Bureaucratic costs associated with an untenable health care model. 25-30% of American healthcare costs are of no value to the person receiving services or the provider of the services. Heck, even standardizing the system for insurance reimbursements would save billions. Take the insurance companies out of the equation and you might have a supportable system. Right-wing America needs to wake up. Your free-market healthcare model will bankrupt the nation. You cannot even defend the existing highest costing model in the world based on healthcare outcomes. Even Cuba can provide healthcare with better outcomes at a fraction of the cost! The healthcare innovations in America occur despite the system, not because of it. Your biggest ray of hope is the VA. Learn from their experience and apply the lessons on a state level.

Ralph said : Guest Report 10 years ago

What no one wants to talk about is the role government policy plays in rising health care costs. Price fixing and under-payments for MEDICAID have a direct effect on costs the private sector must bear. In my 30+ years, I have written off tens of thousands in loss to patients in government programs (Medicare /Medicaid). {MODERATOR: The first comments was posted prematurely and incomplete. Please delete it and edit out this explanation. Thanks}

Ralph said : Guest Report 10 years ago

What no one wants to talk about is the role government policy plays in rising health care costs. Price fixing and under-payments for MEDICAID have a direct effect on costs the private sector must bear. In my 30+ years, I have written off tens of thousands in loss to government programs

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked