EBRI cost conscious decision making by type of plan Dec 15

The rising cost of health care for Americans continues to contribute to self-rationing care in the forms of not filling prescriptions, postponing necessary services and tests, and avoiding needed visits to doctors. Furthermore, health care costs are threatening the livelihood of most American families, according to the Pioneer Institute.

“What Will U.S. Households Pay for Health Care in the Future?” asks the title of a study by the Institute, noting that health care costs for an American family of average income could increase annually to $13,213 by 2025 — and as high as $18,251. Pioneer calculates that this forecasted spend will consume as much as 27% of household income.

[The Department of Commerce calculates that Americans spent $1 in $5 of household income on health care in 2015].

Adding to the discussion of concerns about health care consumers with more “skin in the game,” JAMA Internal Medicine published a letter the week of January 19, 2016, on cost-sharing obligations, high-deductibles, and shopping for health care. Researchers from Harvard and USC surveyed a nationa sample of U.S. adults via GfK’s Knowledge Panel, analyzing HDHP enrollees for attitudes on price shopping, out-of-pocket costs, and health care demand. Increaing a deductible (that is, increasing skin in the game) did not inevitably lead to consumers’ price shopping for health care. “If increasing price shopping is viewed as an important policy goal,” the team wrote, “there is a need for greater availability of price information and innovative approaches to enrollee engagement with this information.”

A third report, from EBRI (the Employee Benefit Research Institute), looked further into the hearts and minds of HDHP enrollees. Findings from the 2015 EBRI/Greenwald & Associates Consumer Engagement in Health Care Survey, published in December 2015, found evidence that HDHP members did exhibit more cost- conscious behaviors compared with traditional plan members such as checking whether the plan would cover care, asking for generic drugs versus brand name Rx’s, talking with doctors about treatment options and costs, and using online cost-tracking tools provided by health plans.

Telehealth-visit-costs-vs-other-urgent-care-options1Health Populi’s Hot Points: Impacts of HDHPs are borne by a large and growing cohort of consumers, including both those who sign up for health insurance at work and shoppers on Federal and State-run health insurance marketplaces. According to an April 2014 Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) report, 65% of health plan enrollees chose silver plans; in these plans, 30% of health care costs were covered by the consumer, and the average deductible in these plans was $2,907 per person.

What consumers have begun to figure out is that cheaper, high quality care is increasingly available outside of hospitals, doctors offices, and emergency rooms in the form of telehealth and digital health channels. The second chart shows that a telehealth visit with, for example, American Well is half the cost of a visit to a primary care doctor, one-third the price of an urgent care visit, and about $700 cheaper than an ER admission.

EBRI interest in having telemed visit 12-16So it is unsurprising that EBRI’s survey found out, for the first time this question was polled in this annual survey, that some one-half of people enrolled in HDHPs are keen to have a telemedicine visit, shown in the third chart. Health consumers have begun to figure out how to use their HDHPs and HSAs, notwithstanding a lack of useful price and quality information. Word-of-mouth is a major driver of referrals in health consumers cottoning on to peer-to-peer healthcare in social networks, both offline and online.

3 Comments on Getting Beyond Consumer Self-Rationing in High-Deductible Health Plans

3 Real-World Reasons the Scripps Study Failed :: Chilmark said : Guest Report 2 years ago

[…] instead (or these days, the IT geek or insurance wonk)? Even if we put aside about the growing financial disincentive to use health insurance, we’ve moved into an era of invisible, ubiquitous utilization, of Minute […]

HealthPopuli.com said : Guest Report 3 years ago

[…] The role of the patient-consumer in health and healthcare cannot be overstated in this emerging area of value-based care, and rising costs. Patients bear increasing financial health-risk, with $1 in every $5 of household spending being allocated to healthcare for every American family, making healthcare costs the #1 pocketbook issue for people across all income strata. One DVT patient explained to me that a particular test for blood clots can cost a patient between $5,000 and $10,000 — that single line item getting a patient-health plan member to their deductible. It’s also a sticker-shock cost that dissuades some patients, according to my expert DVT patient, to forgo the test (which we at THINK-Health consider “self-rationing due to cost“). […]

3 Real-World Reasons the Scripps Study Failed | Chilmark Research said : Guest Report 3 years ago

[…] instead (or these days, the IT geek or insurance wonk)? Even if we put aside about the growing financial disincentive to use health insurance, we’ve moved into an era of invisible, ubiquitous utilization, of […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked