One in two people in the U.S. with employer-sponsored health insurance worry that a major health event in their household could lead to bankruptcy, according to research gathered by West Health and Gallup in Business Speaks: The Future of Employer-Sponsored Insurance.

Gallup and West Health presented their study in a webinar earlier this week; in today’s post, I feature a few key data points that particularly resonate as I celebrate/appreciate yesterday’s U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling on the Affordable Care Act (i.e., California v. Texas) combined with a new study published in JAMA Network Open, discussed below the digital fold in the Hot Points. 

Even in 2021, we still see so-called “job-lock” with workers staying in jobs that offer health insurance benefits. Gallup-West Health found that overall, 16% (1 in 6) of workers stay in an unwanted job for the health insurance benefits. This varies from 21% of Black workers to 14% of White workers, and those earning under $48,000 a year (with 28% staying in an unwanted job for insurance) compared with 10% of people earning $120,000 and over.

One-half of U.S. adults covered by workplace health insurance are concerned about the cost of healthcare rising until they can no longer afford it, and 52% are worried about the cost of prescription drugs they could not afford,

One-half of people “strongly” agreed with allowing the Federal government to set limits on drug price increases or to negotiate prices for certain high-cost drugs that have no competitors, in addition to capping prices for hospitals in certain markets with limited/no competition.

Another 23% of consumers “somewhat” agreed with the two drug pricing control strategies, as well.

Gallup and West Health noted that this intensity of support for price regulation was noteworthy in this study.

Gallup-West Health surveyed 3,870 U.S. adults aged 18 and over in March 2021 for this study.

Health Populi’s Hot Points:   U.S. workers with private insurance more likely report poor access to health care, greater costs of care, and lower satisfaction with care versus people covered by public health insurance plans — whether Medicaid, Medicare, VHA or military coverage. This remarkable finding was reported on June 1, 2021, in Access to Care, Cost of Care, and Satisfaction With Care Among Adults With Private and Public Health Insurance in the US, published in JAMA Network Open.

Why would this be the case, that people insured in commercial/private plans whether employer-sponsored or personally purchased would be so less satisfied with health care (FYI 80% of the study respondents with private insurance were in work-sponsored plans).

The details in the study were that people with private insurance were less likely than folks with Medicare to have a personal physician and more likely to have unstable insurance coverage. Compared with people enrolled in Medicaid, members of private insurance plans were more likely to have medical debt.

It’s important to know that the incidence of medical bankruptcy fell within two years of the implementation of the Affordable Care Act. “The ACA expanded coverage to millions of poor and near-poor families between 2014 and 2016, and the obtaining of health insurance may have staved off financial ruin, perhaps
through a lower accumulation of medical debt,” the study concludes.

Nonetheless, the ACA has not been a panacea ridding Americans of the threat of medical bankruptcy and financial toxicity of health care costs borne by U.S. households. The “Affordable” adjective in the Act’s title has been elusive, and we continue to see a dozen states still not expanding Medicaid to enable health care insurance access to millions of uninsured people. So while we who believe in health care as a civil right and universal health coverage a national objective, we have much work to do to ensure U.S. consumers evolve toward full health citizenship.

As a postscript – on the prescription drug pricing front – watch the line-item in the Gallup-West Health study on driving pricing and U.S. health citizens’ cross-party concurrence for greater regulation. A new poll from STAT looked at the FDA approval process for Aduhelm, the new-new therapy for Alzheimer’s Disease.

Aduhelm is currently has a list price of $56,000 for one year of treatment.

The last graph comes from the survey, conducted by The Harris Poll last week (June 11-13, 2021). The lowest line on the chart shows consumers agreeing with the statement, “I believe the drug is priced fairly.”

Only 15% “strongly agree” that the drug is priced fairly, and 22% “somewhat” agree. One-third are not sure about the pricing, and 28% disagree with the fair-price statement.

There is in Congress some bipartisan concurrence for drug price regulation evolving. In the post-pandemic era, health care costs are rising in health consumers’ minds and at kitchen tables once again, taking the place they had pre-pandemic in polls on Americans’ top health care concerns. This goes, too, for hospitals with respect to surprise billing and out-of-network costs. Watch for the health care stakeholder lobbies to be lobbing campaigns about the value of spending on hospitals, physician care, insurance, and pharma like this new AHIP report.

 

 

2 Comments on One in Two Americans with Work-Based Insurance Worries That Healthcare Costs Could Lead to Bankruptcy

Victoria Hernandez said : Guest Report 3 weeks ago

Hi Jane. This study is scary and sad and more so for a field like health, which is so important and one of the fundamental pillars of human well being. Regardless, bankruptcy may be the answer for some and I always believe it is best to have a good lawyer on your side in such cases.

Andrew Fraser said : Guest Report a month ago

Hello Jane Excellent blog posting highlighting a glaring issue with the US healthcare system. It is truly disheartening to imagine in theses United States, richest country on earth, a citizen can and do face financial ruin because of something completely out of their control- an illness. I too believe that health care and access to healthcare is a civil right and universal health coverage must be a national objective As you pointily stated most people do not realize, that their private health insurance may not be enough to protect them- and may fall in the category of the 66% of the bankruptcy filers who file for bankruptcy protection secondary to a health catastrophe. The hope is the Affordable Care Act serves as a proxy for a national insurance – providing some sort of safety for the vulnerable population.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked